A major new prospective study has reported that women who are underweight or morbidly obese at breast cancer diagnosis are at higher risk of death from all causes than normal weight women. Morbidly obese women are also at increased risk of breast cancer-specific death. The study was designed to investigate the influence of body size on survival after a diagnosis of breast cancer. Both obese and underweight women have been reported to have worse survival than normal weight women who develop breast cancer. However, the optimal body mass index (BMI) range for prognosis has not been established.
The study included 14,948 patients in the After Breast Cancer Pooling Project who were diagnosed with stage I to stage III breast cancer between 1990 and 2006. The women were divided into the following World Health Organization weight categories at diagnosis: underweight (BMI < 18.5 kg/m(2)); normal weight (18.5 to <25); overweight (25 to <30); obese (30 to <35 kg/m(2)); severely obese (35 to <40 kg/m(2)); and morbidly obese (≥40 kg/m(2)). Participants were followed for an average of 7.8 years for breast cancer recurrence and mortality.
A total of 2,140 deaths and 2,065 breast cancer recurrences took place during the follow-up period. Underweight women were 1.6 times more likely to die (i.e., from all causes, not just breast cancer) and morbidly obese women were 1.8 times more likely to die than normal weight women. Morbidly obese women were also at increased risk of breast cancer-specific death. Obese and severely obese women were found to have small increases (~10%) in risk of death compared to normal weight women, but these increases were not statistically significant. Overweight women did not experience any increased risk of death compared to normal weight women. The authors conclude that the study results suggest that degree of obesity influences survival.
Body weight matters less for triple negative breast cancer
Previous studies have also suggested that being merely overweight does not unduly worsen breast cancer prognosis. The study size was large enough to demonstrate convincingly that even some degree of obesity is not very harmful (assuming appropriate breast cancer treatment). Based on this and other studies, we think that overweight and obese breast cancer patients are better off improving their diets and increasing their level of physical activity than focusing primarily on weight loss. Weight loss would be inevitable for those closely following an eating plan based on the information in this website (see our article on how to optimize your breast cancer diet), but we are not going to pretend that eating this way is an easy change to make. A good start would be to eliminate or reduce consumption of the foods on our avoid list and start consuming more foods on our recommended list.
Having said this, there is some evidence that being obese is detrimental to the outlook of women with hormone receptor positive (ER+/PR+) and those with type 2 diabetes, but not those with triple negative (ER-/PR-/HER2-) disease:
- A study that included 3,995 participants in the California Teachers Study found that high BMI was associated with higher breast cancer mortality among women with ER+ tumors but not ER- disease.
- A study of women with triple negative breast cancer found that overweight and obese women did not have a higher risk of distant metastases compared to normal or underweight patients. The results held when stratified by menopausal status.
- Another study of women with triple negative breast cancer treated between 1996 and 2010 found no significant relation between obesity and recurrence-free survival or overall survival.
- A study of breast cancer patients of all receptor status types found that obesity was associated with inferior disease free survival and overall survival in hormone receptor positive breast cancer treated with adjuvant chemotherapy, but not HER2+ or triple negative disease. The authors suggested that hyperinsulinemia (excess circulating insulin) or other factors associated with obesity may predispose hormone receptor positive breast cancer to recurrence.