Butter is not recommended for breast cancer

Made from milk, butter is a rich dietary source of vitamin A, calcium, and conjugated linoleic acid, all of which have been shown to have anticarcinogenic properties. However, butter consumption has been found to be associated with increased risks of leukemia, as well as oral, esophageal, thyroid, stomach, pancreatic, endometrial, colorectal, prostate and testicular cancer. In addition, butter consumption has been found to be associated with increased risk of cardiovascular disease and heart attacks in women as well as in men.

Breast cancer-related effects of consuming butter

Although not all studies of the relationship between breast cancer and dairy foods have found a positive association between butter intake and the risk of breast cancer, many have. Women in the Nurses' Health Study who consumed more butter during high school have been found to have a higher risk of breast cancer in adulthood. Another study found that butter consumption was associated with increased risk of recurrence of early stage breast cancer, especially among premenopausal breast cancer cases. Other U.S, Canadian and European studies have found the use of butter in soups or sauces (i.e., boiled butter), butter at the dinner table, and butter used for frying food to be associated with higher risk of breast cancer.

Additional comments

Ghee is a type of clarified butter used in South Asian cuisine. To make ghee, the water and milk solids are removed from butter by heating to eliminate the water and straining. Consumption of ghee has been associated with cardiovascular disease in India; ghee has an even higher saturated fat content than butter.

Tags: CLA, Indian, butter, calcium, dairy, endometrialCancer, milk, vitaminA

Selected studies

Meat, eggs, dairy products, and risk of breast cancer in the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition (EPIC) cohort American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, June 2009
The present prospective study was designed to investigate the association between meat, egg, and dairy product consumption and risk of breast cancer in the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition (EPIC) study cohort. Information concerning diet was collected from 319,826 women during the period 1992 - 2003. During a median follow-up period of 8.8 years, 7,119 breast cancer cases were diagnosed. Multivariate Cox proportional hazard models were used to calculate disease hazard ratios. No consistent overall association was found between risk of breast cancer and consumption of any of the food groups under study. High consumption of processed meat was associated with a modest increase in breast cancer risk in the categorical model (hazard ratio: 1.10; 95% CI: 1.00 - 1.20; highest versus with lowest quintile: P for trend = 0.07). An association of breast cancer risk with butter consumption for premenopausal women was suggested in subgroup analysis (hazard ratio: 1.28; 95% CI: 1.06 - 1.53; highest compared with lowest quintile: P for trend = 0.21). Between-country heterogeneity was found for red meat consumption (Q statistic = 18.03; P = 0.05) and was significantly explained by the proportion of meat cooked at high temperature (P = 0.023). The authors conclude that they had not consistently identified intakes of meat, eggs, or dairy products as risk factors for breast cancer.

Adolescent diet and risk of breast cancer Breast Cancer Research, February 2003
The current case-control study was designed to determine the associations between diet in early life and the risk of breast cancer in adulthood. The study was conducted among participants in the Nurses' Health Study who completed a questionnaire about their diets during high school. 843 eligible cases were matched with controls on the basis of age. It was found that women who had consumed more eggs, vegetable fat and fiber during high school had a lower risk of breast cancer. Women who consumed more butter had a higher risk.

Intake of conjugated linoleic acid, fat, and other fatty acids in relation to postmenopausal breast cancer: the Netherlands Cohort Study on Diet and Cancer American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, October 2002
Conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), which is present in milk and meat from ruminants, has been shown to have anticarcinogenic activity against breast cancer in animal and in vitro experiments. The present study was designed to evaluated the association between intakes of CLA and other fatty acids and the risk of breast cancer in the Netherlands Cohort Study. Information obtained by means of a validated 150-item food-frequency questionnaire was linked to an existing database with information on specific fatty acids in European foods. There were 941 new cases of breast cancer during a follow-up period of 6.3 years. Associations were calculated for energy-adjusted intakes of fatty acids and CLA-containing food groups (e.g., butter, cheese, milk, other milk products, and meat). CLA intake was found to have a weak, positive association with breast cancer incidence (rate ratio for highest compared with lowest quintile: 1.24, 95% CI: 0.91, 1.69; P for trend = 0.02). Statistically significant positive associations also were found with total trans fatty acids and with saturated fatty acids (borderline). Significant inverse relations were found with monounsaturated and cis-unsaturated fatty acids, whereas the total fat and energy intake of CLA-containing food groups were found not to be related to breast cancer incidence. The authors conclude that the apparent anticarcinogenic properties of CLA in animal and tissue culture models was not confirmed in this epidemiological study of humans.

The effect of dietary exposures on recurrence and mortality in early stage breast cancer Breast Cancer Research and Treatment, September 1998
Here, the effects of diet and body weight in 472 women diagnosed with early-stage breast cancer during 1982 to 1984 were studied with respect to eventual breast cancer recurrence and death. The most powerful effects were observed in premenopausal women. It was found that increasing consumption of butter, margarine, and lard (risk ratio (RR)=1.67; 95% confidence interval (CI)=1.17–2.39) and beer (RR=1.58; CI=1.15–2.17) increased the risk of recurrence, after accounting for disease stage and age. An increased risk of recurrence was also found for consumption of red meat, liver, and bacon, corresponding to approximately a doubling of risk for each number of times per day that foods in this category were consumed (RR=1.93; CI=0.89–4.15). Body weight also increased risk at the rate of 9% (RR=1.09; CI=1.02–1.17) for each kg/m2 (equivalent to about 5.8 pounds for a woman 54 inches tall). For risk of death, the results were similar, but relative body weight was more strongly correlated, increasing risk by 12% per kg/m2 (RR=1.12; CI=1.03–1.22).

Digg this Share this on facebook Tweet and track Review on Stumbleupon Submit to reddit Add to delicious Add to Technorati Buzz up RSS feed




















 

Breast cancer resources | Selected supplements and vitamins | Privacy policy | Search | Disclaimer/about us | Free newsletter/Donate | Sitemap